
The real difference between CarMax and We Buy Any Car is what happens to your car after the sale: CarMax buys cars and sells them, while We Buy Any Car only buys. CarMax is a used car retailer with stores in most states, and buying from the public is how it stocks its lots. We Buy Any Car is a car buying service with branches and home pickup in a variety of states; it does not sell cars, so nobody at the appointment has a reason to put you into another vehicle. Every CarMax fact on this page comes from CarMax's own website.
CarMax and We Buy Any Car side by side
| Question | CarMax | We Buy Any Car |
|---|---|---|
What it is | A used car retailer that also buys cars from the public. | A car buying service. We buy cars and do not sell them. |
How you get an offer | Online from your license plate or VIN in minutes, or at a store. Some cars must be seen in person first. Offers are valid for 7 days. | Free online valuation in about 60 seconds, then an appointment of about an hour where the car is confirmed and the offer is made. |
Where | Stores in most states. At-home pickup in some locations. | Branches and home pickup in a variety of states. |
How you are paid | A bank draft issued at the store once the sale is completed. | Instant secure payment by check, wire, ACH or Zelle, your choice, at the appointment. |
Do you have to buy a car | No. CarMax states that its offer is the same whether you buy from it or not. | No. There is nothing to buy. |
What it buys | "Most cars qualify," in CarMax's words. Cars below its retail standard are sold at its own auctions. | All makes and models, including older, high-mileage and non-running cars and cars with accident history. |
How the offer is made at each
CarMax gives you a number in one of two ways. Online, you enter your license plate or VIN and CarMax returns what it calls a real offer in minutes. In store, the offer follows an appraisal of the car. Either way it is valid for 7 days at any CarMax store, and CarMax says it changes only where the car's condition, use or history differs from what you described. You can make an appointment or drive in whenever a store is open.
We Buy Any Car works in a different order. The online valuation is an estimate built from your car's details and the condition you report. The offer itself comes at an appointment of about an hour, after a Vehicle Acquisition Specialist has confirmed the car matches the online details, looked it over and taken a short test drive. Why the final figure can differ is set out in how we calculate your car offer. Walk-ins are welcome, though an appointment gets you a dedicated time slot.
Where you sell and how you are paid
CarMax sells from stores in most states and buys at the same places; its at-home pickup is offered in some locations and not others. We Buy Any Car has branches and home pickup in a variety of states, and the mobile buying service does the same check, paperwork and payment at your home where it is available. For most sellers the practical question is which is closer.
Payment is where they differ most. CarMax's own guide says it issues a bank draft at the store once you have accepted the offer. We Buy Any Car pays at the end of the appointment by whichever of four methods you choose: a corporate check handed to you, a wire transfer, ACH or Zelle. The details are in how you are paid, and the visit is walked through in get in, get out, get paid.
The honest trade-offs
Neither company is set up to pay a private-party price, and here is why. CarMax reconditions the cars it keeps and sends the rest to its own auctions, so its offer has to leave room for repair costs, the risk a car does not retail and its own margin. A direct buyer like We Buy Any Car may need to recondition a car too, or sell it on to the trade, and prices for the same reasons. A private sale usually brings the highest number and costs you negotiating on price, the listing, the calls and strangers at your address. The four numbers a car can carry are explained in how much is my car worth.
CarMax can be the better choice when you are buying a car from it: the trade is handled in the same transaction, and CarMax says its offer is the same whether you buy or not. It also suits anyone who wants a written number in hand before deciding.
We Buy Any Car can be the better choice when selling is the whole job. The appointment is about an hour, the payment is instant, and cars a retailer would send straight to auction, including ones that do not run, are bought like any other. What we buy is listed in we buy cars.
Which one pays more depends on the car, the local market and the day; we will not claim our number is higher before we have seen your car. The way to find out is to get both: CarMax's offer online or in store, and a free online valuation from We Buy Any Car followed by an appointment. Neither costs anything, and CarMax's week-long window lets you hold one while you collect the other.